Pi Day, celebrated annually on March 14, holds a special place in the hearts of mathematicians and pie enthusiasts alike. Enjoy this year’s Pi Day in a delicious way by transforming a day dedicated to the mathematical constant π (pi) into a celebration of both dessert and savory pies. Here’s a taste of your favorite pies around Fishers, thanks to recommendations from local residents.

key lime pie from taylors bakery

Taylor’s Bakery’s Key Lime Pie: A Zesty Delight

8395 East 116th Street

Starting off with a classic dessert pie, Taylor’s Bakery offers a Key Lime Pie that’s a true testament to the power of simplicity and quality ingredients. Made with real key lime juice, this pie strikes the perfect balance between tartness and sweetness, nested in a light, graham cracker crust. It’s a refreshing choice that reminds us of sunny days and warm breezes to come!

food florist pot pie

The Food Florist’s Chicken Pot Pie: Comfort in a Crust

11850 Allisonville Road

The Food Florist brings to the table a Chicken Pot Pie that’s all about comfort and flavor. Packed with chicken, peas, carrots, corn, and green beans, and enveloped in a flaky, buttery crust, it’s a hearty meal that feels like a warm hug.

Any meal from The Food Florist is easy to put out on the dinner table. Stop by or order online ahead of time for homemade, fresh, local food!

strawberry ice cream pie

Bruster’s Ice Cream Pie: A Frozen Fantasy

12350 Olio Road

For those who like to venture into the colder side of the pie spectrum, Bruster’s offers an ice cream pie that’s nothing short of spectacular. With flavors like chocolate raspberry truffle, sea salt caramel, and rainbow sprinkle cookie, there’s a slice of frozen paradise for everyone. It’s a modern twist on the pie concept, perfect for those who prefer their desserts with a scoop of creativity.

blueberry pie

Generations Pie Company’s Grandma Bessie’s Blueberry Pie: A Taste of Tradition

Located in Fortville and sold during the opening season of the Fishers Farmers Market

Generations Pie Company brings a slice of heritage to the table with Grandma Bessie’s Blueberry Pie. This pie is a beautiful blend of fresh blueberries, lemon, cinnamon, nutmeg, and a sweet crust, offering a taste that’s both nostalgic and delightfully fresh. It’s a celebration of tradition, family recipes, and the simple joy of sharing a slice of pie with loved ones.

pearl street pizza

Pearl Street Pizzeria

10462 Olio Road

Breaking the mold of traditional pie forms, Pearl Street Pizzeria’s hand-tossed pizzas are a great savory option to round out your Pi Day celebration. Their pizza dough is made from scratch and toppings are prepped fresh every day. From classics like Meat Lovers and Margherita to bold flavors like Quattro Formaggio and Mad Greek, there’s a slice for everyone.

Whether you’re in the mood for a classic dessert pie, craving the comfort of a savory pie, or looking to cool down with an ice cream pie, Fishers has a slice for every preference. On March 14, let’s raise a fork to the infinite possibilities of pi(e) and the culinary creativity it inspires in our vibrant community. Happy Pi Day, Fishers! Let’s make it a delicious one.