A few years ago, I tried to make my own pizza at home. Key word: “tried.” The crust was undercooked in some areas, burnt in others, and left much to be desired. Moral of the story: when you’re craving pizza, leave it to the experts. Whether you’re celebrating National Pizza Day or just looking to order pizza for an easy Friday night dinner, here are a few great local options for pizza right here in Fishers.


Rockstone Pizzeria & Pub

11501 Allisonville Road

Rockstone is a locally owned and operated pizzeria and pub specializing in wood-fired pizzas. Unique menu choices include the Wiki Wahoo with ham, pineapple and pepperoncini, Potato Bacon Pie, Taco Pie and Vodkaza made with vodka cream sauce. Gluten free and cauliflower crusts are available, too!

Yelper Kristine H. said, Best pizza and salads in Fishers! When my dad says this pizza is the best he’s had, THAT’S SAYIN’ SOMETHIN’! My dad is a pizza enthusiast and has had more than his fair share of pizza around the Hoosier state.”

Photo by Yelper Zen D.


Pearl Street Pizzeria & Pub

10462 Olio Road

Pearl Street offers a cozy pub vibe in a family-friendly atmosphere, and it’s also under the same ownership as Pure Eatery. Pizza dough is made from scratch daily and options include a hand-tossed style curst or a deep pan pizza crust. Build your own pizza or try something different like the Pear & Gorgonzola or Chicken Alfredo.

Yelper Kenyatte S. said, All I have to say is YUMMY!!! Who knew that pears and cheese on a pizza would be so delicious? It’s my new favorite. The crust was crisp and buttery, the pear and balsamic drizzle gave it just enough sweetness.”

Photo by Yelper Bill B.



11640 Brooks School Road

Get a taste of Italy right here in Fishers at Passione. This authentic Italian pizzeria uses classic wood fire recipes for a unique taste. Menu favorites include the Margarita Fresco pizza, Meat Lovers pizza, Capresi Salad and of course, gelato.

Yelper Kassy M. said, If you want good pizza this is the place to go! If you want Italian inspired Roman pizza, look no further….But make sure you save room for dessert because the gelato is the best I’ve had outside of Rome & the cannolis are to die for. Everything here is top notch, so you have to give this place a try!”

Photo by Yelper Jastina C.


What’s your go-to spot in Fishers for pizza? Do you prefer thin crust or thick crust? Cheese or pepperoni? Or, perhaps most controversial of all: does pineapple belong on a pizza? Let us know your pizza preferences in the comments or on social media.